TV vs. Social Media: Concerts vs. Street Performances?

by Ian Schafer on January 18, 2012

NYC's Naked Cowboy

Unfinished thought:

Television advertising is a concert. Every TV spot is a performance seen synchronously by thousands or millions at a time. Marketers love putting on that show. Each and every time. It’s sexy. People remember it. But they leave.

Marketing within social media is street performance. Street performers perform for the same number of people as concerts do. It’s just asynchronous: they reach thousands or millions, too, but not at the same time. It’s not as sexy for an advertiser, nor does it have as much immediate impact on those large numbers of people, in aggregate. But people interact with those performers over time. They gather in crowds. The performers gradually learn how to work within and make the most of their environments. The crowds take pictures. Stories are shared. The performers become fixtures. They get discovered. It’s serendipitous, and it can be wonderful. And when you’re really committed, they become legend. Naked Cowboy-style.

Both deserve a proper (significant) investment. But I’d rather have the stuff of legend (legends are stories that grow), than the one-off memory that fades. If you can make them work together, you have a media empire, and can tell the story of how it was the people, your audience, your customers that made it all possible — versus just your ad spend.

{ 1 comment }

Happy 30th, Commodore 64.

January 2, 2012

The Commodore 64 is 30 years old today. Here’s video of me getting one on my 7th birthday. Tweet

Read the full article →

An Example of Good Proactive Customer Service.

December 22, 2011

Bravo, Verizon FiOS. Bravo. @ischafer Glad you like the new channels. Tweet anytime you need us or visit bit.ly/pk2e08 for helpful tools ^Tony — Verizon Support (@VerizonSupport) December 22, 2011 Got any other examples of things like this happening that you’d like to share? Post ‘em to the comments below! Also, FiOS is looking to [...]

Read the full article →

One Big Reason Why You Shouldn’t Underestimate Apple’s iAd: Twitter.

December 13, 2011

In today’s WSJ, there’s a story about Apple’s compromises in the mobile ad space, as they face legitimate competition from other players/networks. This is true. But for a conspiracy theorist like me, I see one advantage that can be played against any of their competitors, should they choose to unlock it. In iOS5, Twitter integration [...]

Read the full article →

Social Media & The Art of Storytelling.

October 5, 2011

This was inspired by a recent conversation I had as part of the IAB’s MIXX Spotlight Series during Advertising Week 8. UPDATE: This post is dedicated to Steve Jobs, my biggest storytelling inspiration. Once upon a time, we told stories to each other. Stories meant to make us laugh, cry, or just understand the ‘what [...]

Read the full article →

My Panel at Digiday: Social 2011

September 23, 2011

In case you missed it, here’s the full stream of my panel with the inimitable Reggie Bradford (Vitrue), Stephanie Agresta (Weber Shandwick), and Ari Osur (Forrester). Watch live streaming video from digiday at livestream.com Tweet

Read the full article →

From ClickZ: Digital Requires the Remodeling of the Relic Agency Model

September 13, 2011

From ClickZ and the brilliant Augustine Fou: It is well known that big agencies have been struggling mightily, recently. From the multimillion-dollar accounts being switched without reviews to public laments that clients expect big ideas for free to procurement departments squashing out every last ounce of margin. Is this a temporary headache or is it [...]

Read the full article →

Is Talib Kweli the First Verified Turntable.fm DJ?

August 10, 2011

Here’s Talib Kweli (a favorite of mine) in his own Turntable.fm room: Tweet

Read the full article →

NPR’s “Marketplace” (And Me) On Google+.

July 23, 2011

Marketplace 7-22-11 by Ian Schafer Here’s a quick little piece on NPR’s Marketplace and quick little soundbite on brands’ place within it. For the full transcript, click here. Tweet

Read the full article →

How To Recreate Google+ Circles in Facebook.

June 29, 2011

I’ve been playing around with Google+ (Google’s new social network) for the last hour, and noticed that the concept of “Circles” (groups of friends categorized by relationships) actually exists in Facebook via “Friend Lists”. You can actually group friends on Facebook and customize your newsfeed right now. [EDIT: This feature has been around for about [...]

Read the full article →